Original brick side wall and white bay window overlooking a tidy enclosed garden with evergreen shrubs and scattered autumn leaves.

In Elmhurst's New Zoning Code, an Older House's Footprint Is Worth Something Until It Comes Down

On South Hillside Avenue in Elmhurst's southwest corner, a resident told the City Council in March that his block had seen 10 teardowns and no expansions in six years, with two more teardowns expected. Elmhurst Patch reported his comments, including his estimate that the new houses cost about $1.5 million. In 2006, he said, the same street saw one teardown and four expansions.

Four months after that meeting, on July 20, 2026, the City Council adopted the first comprehensive rewrite of the Elmhurst Zoning Ordinance since 1992. The city prepared it with the planning firm Camiros.

Nonconforming structures in the new code

Many older houses sit closer to a side or front lot line than current setbacks allow. The 2026 code calls these nonconforming structures, and Section 19.3F addresses single-family and two-family dwellings with walls encroaching into a required setback:

"Where a single-family or two-family dwelling permitted within the district is nonconforming because of a principal structure building wall encroachment into a required setback, the structure may be enlarged or extended horizontally or vertically along the same existing plane as the existing perimeter walls, so long as the resulting structure does not violate any other district regulation or increase the extent of the encroachment."

The city flagged this extension of nonconforming walls as one of two special exceptions in its March 9, 2026 presentation to the Committee of the Whole.

Residential zoning districts

The city's March 2026 presentation lists "Remove FAR" among the residential changes. Table 4-1 of the adopted ordinance sets these figures for the single-family districts:

District Minimum lot area Minimum lot width Max building coverage Max height
RE, Residential Estates 12,000 sf 75 ft 25% 35 ft and 2.5 stories
R1 9,000 sf 50 ft 30% 35 ft and 2.5 stories
R1A 10,000 sf 56 ft 30% 35 ft and 2.5 stories
R2 7,260 sf 50 ft 30% 35 ft and 2.5 stories
R2A, new in 2026 6,500 sf 50 ft 30% 35 ft and 2.5 stories

The city created R2A to bring more lots into conformity with their actual size and frontage. Its 2023 notable-changes memo also describes revised front-yard averaging.

The garage rules affect what fits on the lot. A detached garage is capped at 720 square feet and 21 feet high. It must sit 20 feet from the lot line where it takes street access, though alley access is exempt from that distance. Other detached accessory structures generally have to stay 5 feet off interior side and rear lot lines and cannot be larger in footprint than the house.

Older dwelling types and accessory dwelling units

Section 19.2G covers residential dwelling types a district did not allow as of December 7, 1992.

The 2026 code defines an ADU, but it does not carry over the section of ADU standards that appeared in the 2024 public draft. Elmhurst Patch reported in July 2024 that committees had pulled the ADU provision from the draft so it could be considered separately.

The sale prices already reflect two markets

According to the Midwest Real Estate Data Local Market Update for September 2026, with data current as of October 14, Elmhurst's detached median sale price was $685,000 and the average was $1,003,054. Over the 12 months through September 2026, the median was $702,500 and the average was $913,870.

When the average runs about $211,000 above the median for a full year, a smaller group of very expensive sales is pulling it upward. That pattern fits the Hillside block that the resident described to Patch, where houses he valued at about $1.5 million replaced modest ones. The median is a better guide to the market for existing homes, and the average reflects that it shares a price table with new construction.

Conditions this fall have favored buyers more than they did a year ago. In September 2026, detached closed sales fell to 27 from 30 a year earlier, and month-end inventory rose to 70 homes from 63. Average market time increased to 57 days from 48. Sellers received 96.6% of their original list price, compared with 100.6% in September 2025. MRED notes that a single month can look extreme because the sample is small.

Keeping an older house has precedent. Crain's Chicago Business reported in December 2025 on a small 1920s Elmhurst house designed by Harold Zook that was saved from teardown and renovated, in a neighborhood where the paper described old-home demolitions as rampant.

This post is general information, not legal or zoning advice. Before you rely on any of these provisions for a specific property, confirm how they apply with the City of Elmhurst's planning and zoning staff and your own attorney.

Ed Bellock can talk with you about Elmhurst homes. If you own an older home and want to know how a buyer might value it, start with your instant home valuation and then call Ed to talk through the details.

Work With Ed

Ed is here to help you through every step of the real estate process from the search, showings, negotiations, inspection, attorney review, financing, and closing, Work with Ed Today!

Follow Me on Instagram